sidebar_top

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  Scoresheet-talk Rankings 2014                                    

These lists are the result of polls on the Scoresheet-talk list. Rankings are based on a unscientific poll of subscribers to the Scoresheet-talk list.

Members are asked to rank players for a regular continuing league beginning in 2013. Votes are counted on a 10,9,8 ... basis. Thanks here to SS-talk, especially moderator Brian DewBerry-Jones, for continuing this SS-talk tradition and to William Burke for setting up an online mechanism to handle the voting.

Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
CATCHER
Joe Mauer MIN 35 1.9 1 5 320 Buster Posey SF 29 1.1 1 2 346
Carlos Santana CLE 32 1.8 1 4 294 Yadier Molina STL 29 2.2 1 5 313
Brian McCann NYA 35 3.3 1 9 271 Jonathan Lucroy MIL 27 4.4 2 10 233
Matt Wieters BAL 35 4.7 1 7 222 Wilin Rosario COL 26 4.2 2 8 229
Salvador Perez KC 30 3.9 1 7 213 Wilson Ramos WAS 25 5.8 3 9 181
Jason Castro HOU 31 5.4 3 9 173 Miguel Montero ARI 24 6 3 10 168
Yan Gomes CLE 29 7.1 5 10 112 Evan Gattis ATL 25 6.8 4 10 154
Alex Avila DET 24 7.7 4 10 80 Jarrod Saltalamacchia MIA 18 7.4 3 10 100
A.J. Pierzynski BOS 22 8.1 4 10 64 Travis D'Arnaud NYN 17 7.2 2 10 99
Mike Zunino SEA 21 8.2 5 10 59 Carlos Ruiz PHI 14 7.9 5 10 71
John Jaso OAK 13 7.8 3 10 41 Russell Martin PIT 13 8 5 10 65
Jesus Montero SEA 5 6.6 3 10 22 Devin Mesoraco CIN 11 7.7 4 10 58
Chris Iannetta ANA 7 8.1 3 10 20 Yasmani Grandal SD 10 8.2 4 10 48
Derek Norris OAK 7 8.6 6 10 17 A.J. Ellis LA 8 7.2 3 10 46
Dioner Navarro TOR 8 9.2 7 10 14 Welington Castillo CHN 8 9.4 7 10 29
J.P. Arencibia TEX 3 7 6 8 12 Nick Hundley SD 2 6 4 8 14
Jorge Alfaro TEX 5 9 8 10 10 Austin Hedges SD 2 7 6 8 12
Kurt Suzuki MIN 2 6.5 6 7 9 Ryan Doumit ATL 1 7 7 7 6
Gary Sanchez NYA 5 9.4 8 10 8 Tony Sanchez PIT 1 10 10 10 3
Hank Conger ANA 3 9 7 10 6
Josmil Pinto MIN 2 8 7 9 6
Jose Lobaton TAM 1 9 9 9 2
Geovany Soto TEX 2 10 10 10 2
John Buck SEA 2 10 10 10 2
Ryan Hanigan TAM 1 10 10 10 1
FIRST BASE
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Chris Davis BAL 34 2.1 1 6 471 Joey Votto CIN 29 1.3 1 2 340
Prince Fielder TEX 34 2.7 1 6 451 Paul Goldschmidt ARI 29 1.8 1 3 326
Edwin Encarnacion TOR 34 3.1 1 9 439 Freddie Freeman ATL 29 3.3 2 6 280
David Ortiz BOS 34 5.2 1 11 368 Adrian Gonzalez LA 29 4.4 3 7 249
Eric Hosmer KC 33 5.2 1 9 356 Anthony Rizzo CHN 29 5.7 4 10 211
Albert Pujols ANA 34 5.6 1 13 353 Brandon Belt SF 27 5.2 3 9 210
Billy Butler KC 34 7.7 5 11 281 Matt Adams STL 26 7.2 5 10 150
Mike Napoli BOS 33 8 3 15 263 Justin Morneau COL 22 7.9 6 10 113
Jose Abreu CHA 33 8.5 3 15 248 Yonder Alonso SD 18 8.3 7 10 85
Victor Martinez DET 32 9.6 4 16 206 Ryan Howard PHI 19 8.7 6 10 81
Brandon Moss OAK 27 11 7 16 140 Adam LaRoche WAS 16 8.7 7 10 69
Mark Teixeira NYA 30 12 5 16 132 Ike Davis NYN 10 9.5 9 10 35
Adam Lind TOR 26 13 9 16 84 Dan Vogelbach CHN 3 9.3 9 10 11
Jonathan Singleton HOU 19 13 9 16 51 Jordan Pacheco COL 2 10 10 10 6
Adam Dunn CHA 17 13 9 16 46 Garrett Jones MIA 1 7 7 7 6
Corey Hart SEA 23 14 11 16 45 Gaby Sanchez PIT 1 10 10 10 3
Mitch Moreland TEX 18 14 12 16 39
James Loney TAM 15 14 8 16 36
Justin Smoak SEA 16 14 10 16 33
Paul Konerko CHA 8 13 6 16 25
Logan Morrison SEA 6 15 13 16 9
Jordan Lennerton DET 1 13 13 13 3
CJ Cron ANA 1 15 15 15 1
Brett Wallace HOU 2 16 16 16 0
SECOND BASE
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Robinson Cano SEA 35 1.2 1 2 343 Matt Carpenter STL 29 1.6 1 4 330
Dustin Pedroia BOS 35 2 1 4 316 Chase Utley PHI 29 4 1 9 260
Jason Kipnis CLE 34 3.2 2 7 264 Aaron Hill ARI 26 4 1 9 234
Ian Kinsler DET 35 4.5 2 7 227 Brandon Phillips CIN 26 4.7 1 10 216
Jurickson Profar TEX 34 5.5 3 9 186 Jedd Gyorko SD 28 5.8 3 10 203
Howard Kendrick ANA 31 6.5 4 9 141 Neil Walker PIT 28 5.8 2 9 201
Jose Altuve HOU 32 6.9 4 10 132 Anthony Rendon WAS 23 4.6 1 9 193
Omar Infante KC 25 6.9 3 9 103 Martin Prado ARI 23 5.9 3 9 163
Brian Dozier MIN 19 7.8 4 10 60 Daniel Murphy NYN 19 8 3 10 95
Dustin Ackley SEA 12 8.4 5 10 31 Kolten Wong STL 15 8.3 3 10 70
Nick Franklin SEA 12 8.8 7 10 27 Alexander Guerrero LA 10 8.5 5 10 45
Rougned Odor TEX 8 7.8 6 10 26 Marco Scutaro SF 9 8.6 4 10 40
Alberto Callaspo OAK 7 8.3 4 10 19 Rickie Weeks MIL 5 7.4 4 10 28
Gordon Beckham CHA 9 9.2 7 10 16 Dan Uggla ATL 5 8.8 5 10 21
Brian Roberts NYA 4 9 7 10 8 Mark Ellis STL 2 4.5 4 5 17
Kelly Johnson NYA 4 9.8 9 10 5 Danny Espinosa WAS 3 7.3 5 10 17
Jemile Weeks BAL 1 7 7 7 4 Scooter Gennett MIL 3 8.3 7 10 14
Emilio Bonifacio KC 1 8 8 8 3 Josh Rutledge COL 2 8.5 7 10 9
Eddie Rosario MIN 3 10 10 10 3 D.J. LeMahieu COL 2 9.5 9 10 7
Grant Green ANA 2 9.5 9 10 3 Logan Forsythe TAM 1 7 7 7 6
Johnny Giavotella KC 1 9 9 9 2 Darwin Barney CHN 2 10 10 10 6
Jonathan Schoop BAL 2 10 10 10 2
Taylor Lindsey ANA 1 10 10 10 1
Jeff Keppinger CHA 1 10 10 10 1
Ryan Goins TOR 1 10 10 10 1
Delino Deshields HOU 1 10 10 10 1
THIRD BASE
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Miguel Cabrera DET 33 1.2 1 5 323 David Wright NYN 27 1.1 1 4 320
Evan Longoria TAM 32 2.3 1 4 277 Ryan Zimmerman WAS 27 2.9 1 6 272
Adrian Beltre TEX 33 3.6 2 6 245 Pablo Sandoval SF 26 3.6 2 6 245
Manny Machado BAL 32 3.5 1 7 239 Pedro Alvarez PIT 27 5.4 3 9 206
Josh Donaldson OAK 32 5.2 3 8 185 Chase Headley SD 27 5.6 2 9 200
Kyle Seager SEA 30 6.5 4 11 135 Nolan Arenado COL 25 6 2 10 176
Brett Lawrie TOR 29 6.8 3 10 122 Aramis Ramirez MIL 25 6 2 9 175
Miguel Sano MIN 22 7.3 4 11 82 Kris Bryant CHN 14 5.8 2 10 101
David Freese ANA 25 8.9 5 11 53 Chris Johnson ATL 20 8.2 3 10 95
Mike Moustakas KC 26 9 7 11 53 Todd Frazier CIN 18 7.7 5 10 95
Will Middlebrooks BOS 25 9.2 4 11 46 Maikel Franco PHI 11 8.8 4 10 46
Matt Davidson CHA 8 9.2 7 11 14 Juan Uribe LA 7 8.6 4 10 31
Matt Dominguez HOU 9 9.9 9 11 10 Cody Asche PHI 4 9 6 10 16
Trevor Plouffe MIN 9 10 6 11 8 Mark Reynolds MIL 3 8.3 7 9 14
Lonnie Chisenhall CLE 6 9.7 8 11 8 Colin Moran MIA 3 10 10 10 9
DJ Peterson SEA 2 9 9 9 4 Wilmer Flores NYN 2 8.5 8 9 9
Garin Cecchini BOS 4 10 7 11 4 Juan Francisco MIL 2 9 9 9 8
Alex Liddi CHA 2 9.5 8 11 3 Luis Valbuena CHN 1 9 9 9 4
Danny Valencia KC 1 9 9 9 2 Christian Villanueava CHN 1 10 10 10 3
Joey Gallo TEX 2 10 10 10 2
Scott Sizemore NYA 1 11 11 11 0
SHORTSTOP
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Jose Reyes TOR 32 2.7 1 8 266 Troy Tulowitzki COL 31 1.1 1 2 369
Ben Zobrist TAM 32 3.8 1 9 229 Hanley Ramirez LA 30 2.3 1 4 321
Xander Bogaerts BOS 27 2.7 1 8 223 Andrelton Simmons ATL 30 4.4 1 9 259
Elvis Andrus TEX 32 4.9 1 10 194 Ian Desmond WAS 29 4.4 2 9 250
J.J. Hardy BAL 31 5.1 1 10 182 Jean Segura MIL 29 5 3 7 231
Jed Lowrie OAK 30 6 2 10 151 Starlin Castro CHN 27 7 3 10 162
Asdrubal Cabrera CLE 22 6.6 1 10 96 Jhonny Peralta STL 23 6.4 3 10 152
Carlos Correa HOU 16 5.4 2 10 89 Javier Baez CHN 14 4.9 2 9 114
Addison Russell OAK 15 5.6 3 10 81 Jimmy Rollins PHI 19 8.3 3 10 90
Brad Miller SEA 19 7.2 4 10 72 Everth Cabrera SD 17 7.9 5 10 87
Alexei Ramirez CHA 12 6 3 9 60 Brandon Crawford SF 15 7.9 4 10 77
Erick Aybar ANA 15 7.8 1 10 48 Zack Cozart CIN 15 8 4 10 75
Francisco Lindor CLE 15 7.8 4 10 48 Jordy Mercer PIT 9 8.7 6 10 39
Yunel Escobar TAM 10 6.8 2 10 42 Corey Seager LA 6 8.3 7 10 28
Jose Iglesias DET 12 8 2 10 36 Didi Gregorius ARI 5 7.8 6 10 26
Derek Jeter NYA 8 8 3 10 24 Chris Owings ARI 3 9 8 10 12
Alcides Escobar KC 3 7.3 6 9 11 Daniel Descalso STL 2 7 7 7 12
Eric Sogard OAK 2 8 7 9 6 Ruben Tejada NYN 2 9.5 9 10 7
Adalberto Mondesi KC 2 9 8 10 4 Arismendy Alcantara CHN 2 10 10 10 6
Hunter Dozier KC 1 8 8 8 3 Rafael Furcal MIA 1 8 8 8 5
Tim Beckham TAM 1 9 9 9 2 Pete Kozma STL 1 10 10 10 3
Christian Colon KC 1 10 10 10 1
Jonathan Villar HOU 1 10 10 10 1
Mike Aviles CLE 1 10 10 10 1
OUTFIELD
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Mike Trout ANA 25 1 1 1 750 Andrew McCutchen PIT 24 1.5 1 3 851
Shin-Soo Choo TEX 25 4.6 2 11 659 Bryce Harper WAS 24 2.5 1 7 829
Jose Bautista TOR 25 4.9 2 10 653 Carlos Gonzalez COL 24 4 1 7 793
Adam Jones BAL 24 3.9 2 7 650 Giancarlo Stanton MIA 23 4.7 1 15 744
Jacoby Ellsbury NYA 25 6.1 2 10 623 Ryan Braun MIL 23 6.8 1 27 694
Wil Myers TAM 24 5.6 2 11 609 Yasiel Puig LA 23 8.1 2 22 665
Yoenis Cespedes OAK 25 8.2 3 16 569 Matt Holliday STL 24 10 4 19 648
Josh Hamilton ANA 25 11 3 25 496 Justin Upton ATL 22 7.9 2 16 641
Alex Gordon KC 24 10 3 22 494 Jason Heyward ATL 23 9.5 4 22 632
Carlos Beltran NYA 25 11 3 23 490 Matt Kemp LA 24 11 5 27 619
Austin Jackson DET 24 11 3 26 489 Jay Bruce CIN 23 11 6 23 604
Byron Buxton MIN 20 12 2 32 383 Carlos Gomez MIL 23 11 5 25 600
Alex Rios TEX 22 16 5 33 322 Allen Craig STL 22 15 5 25 493
Dexter Fowler HOU 22 17 5 31 319 Hunter Pence SF 23 16 8 24 486
Nick Swisher CLE 22 18 10 28 296 Domonic Brown PHI 23 17 1 24 456
Shane Victorino BOS 23 18 7 26 293 Jayson Werth WAS 23 18 8 26 449
Colby Rasmus TOR 20 17 5 33 287 Starling Marte PIT 18 17 11 27 356
Desmond Jennings TAM 20 17 9 26 273 Michael Cuddyer COL 19 19 7 28 346
Brett Gardner NYA 22 21 10 30 218 Oscar Taveras STL 17 17 7 30 341
Torii Hunter DET 18 21 10 32 189 Mark Trumbo ARI 18 19 9 27 323
Leonys Martin TEX 17 20 9 29 185 Andre Ethier LA 18 19 13 26 320
George Springer HOU 16 20 4 33 174 Curt Granderson NYN 20 21 9 30 319
Nick Markakis BAL 18 22 12 31 171 Christian Yelich MIA 17 20 10 28 292
Coco Crisp OAK 16 21 10 30 164 Carl Crawford LA 16 20 8 29 268
Oswaldo Arcia MIN 16 21 11 32 154 Khris Davis MIL 14 24 13 30 187
Daniel Nava BOS 13 21 10 31 137 Peter Bourjos STL 14 24 14 29 182
Alfonso Soriano NYA 16 24 11 33 120 Carlos Quentin SD 13 25 15 30 163
Jackie Bradley BOS 17 24 13 33 120 Gregory Polanco PIT 8 19 12 28 143
Chris Carter HOU 16 24 9 32 118 Billy Hamilton CIN 12 26 18 30 137
Norichika Aoki KC 16 24 12 33 112 B.J. Upton ATL 10 23 12 30 136
Michael Bourn CLE 17 25 17 32 100 Will Venable SD 10 24 17 30 126
Alejandro DeAza CHA 15 25 15 32 98 Denard Span WAS 9 24 16 28 120
Nick Castellanos DET 12 23 13 33 97 Angel Pagan SF 9 24 17 30 119
Josh Reddick OAK 12 24 13 32 89 Gerardo Parra ARI 7 21 13 26 115
Adam Eaton CHA 18 26 18 32 87 Marlon Byrd PHI 7 23 10 30 97
Dayan Viciedo CHA 16 27 7 33 70 Ben Revere PHI 7 23 18 30 95
Michael Brantley CLE 12 26 18 32 65 Albert Almora CHN 6 22 16 30 89
Clint Frazier CLE 5 18 12 25 63 Jorge Soler CHN 6 23 14 28 86
Josh Willingham MIN 8 24 14 31 59 Cameron Maybin SD 6 26 20 29 68
Avisail Garcia CHA 11 26 15 32 55 A.J. Pollock ARI 4 23 16 30 57
Kole Calhoun ANA 10 26 21 33 52 Joc Pederson LA 4 24 21 27 54
Matt Joyce TAM 13 28 16 33 41 Michael Morse SF 5 26 22 30 54
Lorenzo Cain KC 12 28 20 33 34 Chris_B Young NYN 4 25 21 29 50
Jason Kubel MIN 5 27 22 33 20 Jon Jay STL 3 21 17 29 47
Melky Cabrera TOR 6 28 18 33 18 Marcell Ozuna MIA 3 23 23 24 41
Ichiro Suzuki NYA 3 27 20 30 13 Austin Meadows PIT 3 28 25 30 27
Franklin Gutierrez SEA 2 25 17 33 12 Nate McLouth WAS 2 24 22 26 26
Raul Ibanez ANA 2 25 20 30 12 David Dahl COL 2 25 19 30 25
David DeJesus TAM 4 28 21 32 11 Corey Dickerson COL 3 29 28 30 24
Michael Saunders SEA 2 26 26 26 10 Alfredo Marte ARI 1 14 14 14 23
Bubba Starling KC 2 28 23 33 6 Gregor Blanco SF 2 27 24 30 20
Aaron Hicks MIN 3 29 25 32 5 Junior Lake CHN 2 27 25 29 20
David Murphy CLE 1 26 26 26 5 Jose Tabata PIT 1 19 19 19 18
Jonny Gomes BOS 2 29 25 32 5 Nate Schierholtz CHN 1 24 24 24 13
Mike Carp BOS 2 29 26 32 4 Darin Ruf PHI 1 25 25 25 12
Henry Urrutia BAL 1 28 28 28 3 Drew Stubbs COL 1 25 25 25 12
Michael Choice TEX 3 30 29 33 2 Justin Ruggiano CHN 1 26 26 26 11
Rajai Davis DET 1 30 30 30 1 Jake Marisnick MIA 1 28 28 28 9
Robbie Grossman HOU 2 31 29 33 0 Ryan Ludwick CIN 1 28 28 28 9
Craig Gentry OAK 1 33 33 33 -2 Josh Bell PIT 1 29 29 29 8
Michael Taylor WAS 1 33 33 33 -2 Chris Denorfia SD 1 29 29 29 8
Eric Young NYN 1 30 30 30 7
Caleb Gindl MIL 1 30 30 30 7
Cody Ross ARI 1 30 30 30 7
Charlie Blackmon COL 1 30 30 30 7
STARTERS
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Yu Darvish TEX 21 2.3 1 7 1022 Clayton Kershaw LA 20 3.2 1 46 1155
Felix Hernandez SEA 21 2.6 1 6 1017 Stephen Strasburg WAS 20 5.8 2 40 1103
Justin Verlander DET 21 3.8 1 7 991 Adam Wainwright STL 20 7 2 47 1079
David Price TAM 21 4.1 2 7 984 Zack Greinke LA 20 8.1 2 18 1059
Max Scherzer DET 20 4.3 1 7 934 Madison Bumgarner SF 19 5.4 2 12 1056
Chris Sale CHA 20 4.5 1 10 930 Cliff Lee PHI 19 9 3 48 988
Anibal Sanchez DET 21 10 7 21 861 Matt Cain SF 20 13 5 23 960
Matt Moore TAM 21 12 6 25 824 Cole Hamels PHI 20 13 3 49 959
James Shields KC 19 10 5 18 778 Jordan Zimmermann WAS 20 14 3 50 945
Jon Lester BOS 20 13 8 23 754 Mat Latos CIN 20 14 5 27 936
Jered Weaver ANA 20 14 5 45 740 Gerrit Cole PIT 19 14 4 41 892
Justin Masterson CLE 21 17 6 24 718 Jose Fernandez MIA 16 5.7 2 21 885
Masahiro Tanaka NYA 18 14 6 31 663 Gio Gonzalez WAS 18 14 5 26 854
Hisashi Iwakuma SEA 17 14 6 34 637 Homer Bailey CIN 18 17 1 34 790
Hiroki Kuroda NYA 20 20 9 41 624 Shelby Miller STL 19 20 4 34 785
Alex Cobb TAM 17 15 5 41 606 Michael Wacha STL 19 20 8 44 777
Taijuan Walker SEA 20 22 9 47 583 Doug Fister WAS 19 21 8 36 764
C.J. Wilson ANA 19 21 13 37 573 Julio Teheran ATL 19 22 5 41 751
Clay Buchholz BOS 19 21 9 30 570 Johnny Cueto CIN 19 22 9 35 749
CC Sabathia NYA 20 24 9 41 547 Kris Medlen ATL 18 20 5 39 732
Sonny Gray OAK 17 21 9 43 512 Mike Minor ATL 19 23 9 43 725
Danny Salazar CLE 16 19 8 50 508 Hyun-Jin Ryu LA 16 20 7 38 662
Chris Archer TAM 18 23 12 48 505 Andrew Cashner SD 17 23 6 38 652
Jarrod Parker OAK 20 27 17 44 474 Jeff Samardzija CHN 19 28 11 41 632
R.A. Dickey TOR 19 27 10 50 466 Patrick Corbin ARI 17 25 8 49 615
Corey Kluber CLE 18 27 17 40 430 Francisco Liriano PIT 17 27 10 48 585
A.J. Griffin OAK 18 27 16 36 429 Tony Cingrani CIN 18 29 8 46 585
John Lackey BOS 19 29 14 47 418 Matt Harvey NYN 13 19 3 42 553
Rick Porcello DET 19 31 10 48 387 Zack Wheeler NYN 19 33 15 48 541
Chris Tillman BAL 17 29 5 47 383 Lance Lynn STL 16 28 15 38 530
Kevin Gausman BAL 16 30 12 44 344 Yovani Gallardo MIL 16 29 9 48 520
Jake Peavy BOS 16 30 14 50 329 Wade Miley ARI 18 33 17 46 501
Drew Smyly DET 15 29 13 44 328 Archie Bradley ARI 13 28 3 45 436
Jose Quintana CHA 15 30 16 48 314 Tim Lincecum SF 16 35 16 49 417
Ivan Nova NYA 17 33 15 49 301 Ian Kennedy SD 17 37 22 50 416
Martin Perez TEX 14 32 18 46 273 Alex Wood ATL 14 32 18 48 411
Dan Straily OAK 15 34 14 49 262 Brandon Beachy ATL 13 31 8 47 395
Dylan Bundy BAL 9 24 10 43 239 Kyle Lohse MIL 14 33 22 50 392
Ricky Nolasco MIN 14 35 20 48 229 Nate Eovaldi MIA 12 33 13 50 337
Jeremy Hellickson TAM 11 32 19 45 215 Tyson Ross SD 13 36 13 45 331
Yordano Ventura KC 12 35 23 47 198 Dan Haren LA 12 34 17 49 324
Scott Kazmir OAK 15 38 30 49 194 Josh Johnson SD 12 35 18 47 316
Mark Buehrle TOR 12 35 17 47 190 Tim Hudson SF 13 40 24 49 280
Derek Holland TEX 14 38 12 50 188 Bartolo Colon NYN 11 37 10 49 269
Wei-Yin Chen BAL 12 35 19 48 187 Jaime Garcia STL 11 37 16 47 269
Alexi Ogando TEX 12 36 20 49 178 Carlos Martinez STL 10 35 20 49 263
Mark Appel HOU 8 29 13 50 177 Mike Leake CIN 9 34 21 48 243
Brandon Morrow TOR 9 34 14 47 153 Jonathon Niese NYN 10 37 24 47 241
Hector Santiago ANA 8 36 25 44 124 Noah Syndergaar NYN 10 37 25 50 238
Miguel Gonzalez BAL 9 38 30 50 113 Jameson Taillon PIT 9 36 20 49 221
Bud Norris BAL 8 37 21 47 111 Jhoulys Chacin COL 9 37 7 50 215
Kyle Zimmer KC 5 29 20 44 108 Marco Estrada MIL 9 38 29 47 208
Tyler Skaggs ANA 9 41 26 50 92 Brandon McCarthy ARI 10 41 31 50 205
Jeremy Guthrie KC 5 33 21 48 91 Joe Kelly STL 7 33 21 47 195
Garrett Richards ANA 9 42 27 49 83 Travis Wood CHN 8 37 17 50 193
Zach McAllister CLE 7 39 16 50 81 Trevor Cahill ARI 9 40 31 49 191
Scott Feldman HOU 7 40 20 48 78 Wily Peralta MIL 8 37 15 49 190
Jason Vargas KC 5 36 17 48 74 Josh Beckett LA 8 38 2 50 187
James Paxton SEA 8 42 35 47 73 Jonathan Gray COL 6 33 20 46 169
Matt Harrison TEX 9 43 24 48 70 Dillon Gee NYN 8 40 27 49 166
Trevor Bauer CLE 8 43 36 49 68 Wandy Rodriguez PIT 7 39 21 50 151
Aaron Sanchez TOR 5 38 27 46 66 Edwin Jackson CHN 7 41 19 50 143
Alex Meyer MIN 7 42 36 48 66 Henderson Alvarez MIA 8 44 39 50 135
Phil Hughes MIN 8 43 35 50 65 Charlie Morton PIT 5 35 23 41 129
Tommy Milone OAK 4 37 24 46 57 Cory Luebke SD 4 31 19 43 121
Danny Duffy KC 5 40 34 47 53 Robert Stephenson CIN 5 38 24 49 117
Ryan Dempster BOS 3 34 29 39 52 Ross Detwiler WAS 4 34 13 48 108
Henry Owens BOS 4 39 30 45 50 Lucas Giolito WAS 3 27 19 36 103
Jake Odorizzi TAM 5 42 33 50 46 Chad Billingsley LA 4 36 27 50 100
Felix Doubront BOS 4 41 33 49 41 Eric Stults SD 4 37 26 50 97
Erasmo Ramirez SEA 4 41 33 49 40 Jacob Turner MIA 4 39 35 43 89
Marcus Stroman TOR 5 44 33 50 37 Andrew Heaney MIA 3 33 20 46 84
Jarred Cosart HOU 5 45 41 50 31 Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez PHI 4 40 34 50 83
Neftali Feliz TEX 3 41 31 47 30 Kyle Crick SF 4 42 27 49 76
John Danks CHA 4 44 39 50 28 Jorge DeLaRosa COL 3 37 31 45 73
Michael Pineda NYA 5 45 39 49 28 Tyler Glasnow PIT 4 43 38 48 73
Kohl Stewart MIN 2 38 28 47 27 Julio Urias LA 3 37 31 50 71
Wade Davis KC 3 42 34 50 26 Randall Delgado ARI 3 39 30 48 65
Kevin Correia MIN 1 26 26 26 25 Jeff Locke PIT 3 41 30 47 60
Mike Foltynewicz HOU 3 43 39 48 24 Braden Shipley ARI 2 32 28 36 58
Brett Oberholtzer HOU 3 44 35 50 22 Eddie Butler COL 2 37 35 38 49
Shaun Marcum CLE 3 44 37 48 21 Jenrry Mejia NYN 3 45 38 49 49
Mike Pelfrey MIN 1 32 32 32 19 Ryan Vogelsong SF 3 47 44 49 43
Joe Blanton ANA 1 35 35 35 16 Gavin Floyd ATL 2 44 38 50 34
Drew Pomeranz OAK 3 46 45 48 14 Josh Collmenter ARI 1 28 28 28 33
Luke Hochevar KC 1 39 39 39 12 Edinson Volquez PIT 1 33 33 33 28
Allen Webster BOS 1 39 39 39 12 Max Fried SD 2 47 46 48 28
Erik Johnson CHA 1 39 39 39 12 Arodys Vizcaino CHN 1 35 35 35 26
Zach Britton BAL 1 41 41 41 10 Chad Gaudin PHI 1 36 36 36 25
Lucas Harrell HOU 1 42 42 42 9 Roberto Hernandez PHI 1 37 37 37 24
Kyle Gibson MIN 1 43 43 43 8 Tanner Roark WAS 1 39 39 39 22
Drew Hutchison TOR 1 45 45 45 6 Tom Gorzelanny MIL 1 41 41 41 20
Danny Hultzen SEA 2 49 48 49 5 Burch Smith SD 1 42 42 42 19
Lance McCullers HOU 1 48 48 48 3 Jesse Biddle PHI 1 42 42 42 19
Taylor Guerrieri TAM 1 49 49 49 2 Tyler Thornburg MIL 1 42 42 42 19
Sean Manaea KC 1 49 49 49 2 Robbie Erlin SD 1 43 43 43 18
Dallas Keuchel HOU 1 50 50 50 1 Mike Fiers MIL 1 44 44 44 17
Carlos Carrasco CLE 1 50 50 50 1 Casey Kelly SD 1 44 44 44 17
Anthony Ranaudo BOS 1 50 50 50 1 Jeff Francis CIN 1 48 48 48 13
Brett Anderson COL 1 49 49 49 12
Rafael Montero NYN 1 50 50 50 11
RELIEF PITCHERS
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Greg Holland KC 22 2.6 1 6 184 Craig Kimbrel ATL 22 1.3 1 4 257
Koji Uehara BOS 20 2.4 1 8 172 Aroldis Chapman CIN 21 3 1 7 210
David Robertson NYA 18 3.4 1 7 136 Kenley Jansen LA 19 2.6 1 6 198
Joe Nathan DET 20 4.3 1 10 134 Sergio Romo SF 17 4.6 3 7 142
Grant Balfour TAM 13 5.5 2 9 72 Trevor Rosenthal STL 14 4.2 2 9 123
Glen Perkins MIN 10 5.8 3 9 52 Mark Melancon PIT 12 5.6 2 10 89
Jim Johnson OAK 6 2.8 1 5 49 Tyler Clippard WAS 14 7.9 6 10 71
Sean Doolittle OAK 9 5.8 1 10 47 Jason Grilli PIT 11 6.9 5 10 67
Luke Gregerson OAK 9 6 2 10 45 Jonathon Papelbon PHI 11 7.8 5 10 57
Casey Janssen TOR 12 7.9 6 10 37 Rafael Soriano WAS 9 7.4 2 10 50
Ryan Cook OAK 5 5 1 8 30 Rex Brothers COL 7 6.1 3 9 48
Jake McGee TAM 7 8 6 10 21 Huston Street SD 7 6.9 4 9 43
Kelvin Herrera KC 4 5.8 3 9 21 Joaquin Benoit SD 8 8.5 6 10 36
Junichi Tazawa BOS 5 6.8 5 9 21 Steve Cishek MIA 6 7 3 10 36
Ernesto Frieri ANA 7 8.9 8 10 15 Paco Rodriguez LA 6 7.2 4 9 35
Tanner Scheppers TEX 3 6 6 6 15 Addison Reed ARI 6 7.8 6 10 31
Cody Allen CLE 3 6 3 9 15 Brad Ziegler ARI 5 8.2 6 10 24
Edward Mujica BOS 2 4 4 4 14 Kevin Siegrist STL 3 6 2 10 21
Nate Jones CHA 3 6.7 3 10 13 J.J. Hoover CIN 3 8.7 8 10 13
Jesse Crain HOU 2 6.5 5 8 9 Jim Henderson MIL 2 7 5 9 12
John Axford CLE 3 8.3 6 10 8 Sean Marshall CIN 2 7.5 5 10 11
Sergio Santos TOR 3 8.3 7 10 8 Justin Wilson PIT 1 4 4 4 9
Joakim Soria TEX 4 9 7 10 8 J.J. Putz ARI 2 8.5 7 10 9
Kevin Jepsen ANA 1 3 3 3 8 Jonny Venters ATL 1 6 6 6 7
Joel Peralta TAM 4 9 8 10 8 Antonio Bastardo PHI 2 9.5 9 10 7
Tommy Hunter BAL 3 8.3 8 9 8 Bobby Parnell NYN 1 7 7 7 6
Joe Smith ANA 2 7.5 6 9 7 Craig Stammen WAS 1 7 7 7 6
Darren O'Day BAL 3 8.7 7 10 7 Jordan Walden ATL 1 7 7 7 6
Robbie Ross TEX 1 4 4 4 7 Vin Mazzaro PIT 1 7 7 7 6
Neal Cotts TEX 1 6 6 6 5 Alfredo Simon CIN 1 8 8 8 5
Matt Thornton NYA 2 9 8 10 4 A.J. Ramos MIA 1 8 8 8 5
Eric O'Flaherty OAK 2 9 8 10 4 Drew Storen WAS 1 9 9 9 4
Steve Delabar TOR 2 9 8 10 4 Santiago Casilla SF 1 10 10 10 3
Brett Cecil TOR 1 7 7 7 4 Heath Hembree SF 1 10 10 10 3
Tim Collins KC 1 7 7 7 4
Aaron Loup TOR 1 8 8 8 3
Brian Matusz BAL 1 8 8 8 3
Danny Farquhar SEA 1 9 9 9 2
Charlie Furbush SEA 1 9 9 9 2
Louis Coleman KC 1 9 9 9 2
Heath Bell TAM 1 10 10 10 1
Tom Wilhelmsen SEA 1 10 10 10 1
ROOKIES
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Byron Buxton MIN 18 3.8 1 16 489 Archie Bradley ARI 15 4.4 1 9 489
Xander Bogaerts BOS 18 3.9 1 13 488 Oscar Taveras STL 14 2.8 1 15 479
Miguel Sano MIN 18 5.9 2 15 451 Gregory Polanco PIT 15 6 2 15 465
Taijuan Walker SEA 17 5.1 1 9 440 Kris Bryant CHN 15 6.8 1 25 453
Jose Abreu CHA 18 7.8 2 27 418 Javier Baez CHN 12 3.2 1 9 405
Masahiro Tanaka NYA 15 4.5 1 16 398 Jameson Taillon PIT 14 9.5 2 22 385
Kevin Gausman BAL 18 9.3 3 16 391 Noah Syndergaar NYN 13 9.8 4 24 353
Carlos Correa HOU 17 9.8 1 28 361 Travis D'Arnaud NYN 14 12 1 29 345
Addison Russell OAK 16 9.2 4 16 349 Robert Stephenson CIN 13 11 5 24 339
Francisco Lindor CLE 18 12 3 25 346 Albert Almora CHN 13 13 5 25 310
George Springer HOU 17 12 2 28 328 Maikel Franco PHI 14 15 4 27 305
Dylan Bundy BAL 17 13 7 24 305 Billy Hamilton CIN 13 14 3 30 297
Yordano Ventura KC 15 12 5 21 292 Kolten Wong STL 15 18 5 29 292
Mark Appel HOU 15 16 4 29 228 Lucas Giolito WAS 9 9 5 14 252
Nick Castellanos DET 16 17 9 30 222 Jorge Soler CHN 12 17 5 29 244
Jackie Bradley BOS 16 17 9 29 219 Andrew Heaney MIA 12 17 9 28 239
Kyle Zimmer KC 13 14 6 22 216 Jonathan Gray COL 9 12 2 28 225
Clint Frazier CLE 10 16 7 29 146 Tyler Glasnow PIT 10 15 8 27 219
Alex Meyer MIN 12 20 11 29 138 Chris Owings ARI 10 16 4 28 210
Rougned Odor TEX 11 19 10 28 138 Carlos Martinez STL 7 8.3 1 17 201
Jonathan Singleton HOU 15 22 8 29 135 Alexander Guerrero LA 9 16 5 28 187
Aaron Sanchez TOR 12 21 16 29 123 Corey Seager LA 11 20 10 27 184
Matt Davidson CHA 9 19 7 28 104 Kyle Crick SF 9 17 6 24 176
Jake Odorizzi TAM 10 21 12 30 103 Joc Pederson LA 11 21 11 30 175
James Paxton SEA 8 18 5 26 103 Julio Urias LA 7 15 8 27 156
Henry Owens BOS 8 18 11 27 101 Austin Hedges SD 9 20 8 30 152
Gary Sanchez NYA 7 18 8 25 90 Max Fried SD 8 19 10 28 148
Trevor Bauer CLE 8 20 8 27 89 Eddie Butler COL 6 16 12 21 124
Adalberto Mondesi KC 8 20 14 27 88 Austin Meadows PIT 8 22 2 30 121
Josmil Pinto MIN 8 21 10 28 78 Christian Bethancourt ATL 7 22 14 26 108
Marcus Stroman TOR 7 21 16 26 71 Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez PHI 5 18 9 30 97
Erik Johnson CHA 5 17 7 25 68 A.J. Cole WAS 5 18 12 23 96
Jorge Alfaro TEX 8 23 15 29 63 Lucas Sims ATL 5 18 13 21 96
Bubba Starling KC 7 22 4 29 60 Jake Marisnick MIA 6 22 16 27 92
Garin Cecchini BOS 6 21 16 28 58 Jenrry Mejia NYN 4 15 10 21 90
Danny Hultzen SEA 4 18 12 22 53 Colin Moran MIA 6 22 16 30 88
Jonathan Schoop BAL 6 23 15 30 46 Matt Wisler SD 6 23 14 29 87
Marcus Semien CHA 3 18 12 24 39 Arismendy Alcantara CHN 5 20 13 23 84
DJ Peterson SEA 3 18 12 25 38 Kevin Siegrist STL 3 10 3 18 81
Allen Webster BOS 3 19 15 22 37 Casey Kelly SD 5 22 17 28 76
Mike Foltynewicz HOU 5 24 19 29 34 Wilmer Flores NYN 5 22 13 30 74
Michael Choice TEX 8 27 25 28 32 Alen Hanson PIT 5 22 17 26 74
Alex Colome TAM 2 15 9 21 32 Rafael Montero NYN 5 23 19 30 72
Henry Urrutia BAL 5 25 15 30 31 Kyuji Fujikawa CHN 3 15 8 25 66
Hak Ju Lee TAM 5 26 16 30 26 David Dahl COL 5 25 15 30 62
Hunter Harvey BAL 3 23 20 26 25 Mike Olt CHN 4 22 16 29 59
Kohl Stewart MIN 4 26 23 30 22 Zach Lee LA 3 19 11 26 54
Joey Gallo TEX 4 26 18 30 20 Tony Sanchez PIT 3 20 13 27 51
Jesus Aguilar CLE 1 11 11 11 20 Mike Fiers MIL 2 14 9 19 46
Brandon Workman BOS 1 13 13 13 18 J.P. Crawford PHI 3 22 13 30 44
Bruce Rondon DET 4 27 22 30 17 CJ Edwards CHN 3 23 19 29 41
Christian Colon KC 2 24 21 27 14 Jesse Biddle PHI 2 17 10 24 40
Ian Krol DET 1 20 20 20 11 Braden Shipley ARI 2 18 17 19 38
Caleb Thielbar MIN 1 20 20 20 11 Hunter Renfroe SD 2 20 14 25 35
Hunter Dozier KC 1 20 20 20 11 Edwin Escobar SF 2 20 13 26 35
Eddie Rosario MIN 2 26 25 27 10 Phillip Ervin CIN 1 7 7 7 30
Robbie Ray DET 2 27 23 30 9 Jeurys Familia NYN 2 23 22 24 28
Max Stassi HOU 1 22 22 22 9 Zach Eflin SD 2 23 21 25 28
Jose Berrios MIN 1 22 22 22 9 Brad Boxberger TAM 1 10 10 10 27
Taylor Guerrieri TAM 2 27 25 29 8 Eury DeLaRosa ARI 1 11 11 11 26
John Lamb KC 1 23 23 23 8 Justin Nicolino MIA 2 25 19 30 25
Eric Jagielo NYA 1 23 23 23 8 Dominic Smith NYN 2 26 23 29 22
Blake Swihart BOS 2 27 25 29 8 Nick Noonan SF 1 15 15 15 22
Eduardo Rodriguez BAL 3 29 28 30 7 Burch Smith SD 1 16 16 16 21
CJ Cron ANA 2 28 25 30 7 Alex Reyes STL 1 17 17 17 20
Engel Beltre TEX 1 25 25 25 6 Josh Bell PIT 2 28 27 29 18
Kensuke Tanaka TEX 1 25 25 25 6 Jesse Winker CIN 1 19 19 19 18
Sean Manaea KC 1 25 25 25 6 Joe Wieland SD 1 19 19 19 18
Hernan Perez DET 1 26 26 26 5 Henry Rodriguez CIN 1 20 20 20 17
Dorssys Paulino CLE 1 26 26 26 5 Heath Hembree SF 2 29 28 30 16
Dellin Betances NYA 1 26 26 26 5 Kevin Franklin CIN 1 21 21 21 16
Anthony Ranaudo BOS 2 29 28 30 4 Neftali Soto CIN 1 23 23 23 14
Michael Ynoa OAK 1 27 27 27 4 Arodys Vizcaino CHN 1 23 23 23 14
Asher Wojciechowski HOU 1 28 28 28 3 Wei-Chung Wang MIL 1 23 23 23 14
Trey Ball BOS 1 29 29 29 2 Rymer Liriano SD 2 30 30 30 14
Abraham Almonte SEA 1 29 29 29 2 David Holmberg CIN 1 24 24 24 13
Courtney Hawkins CHA 1 29 29 29 2 Taylor Jungmann MIL 1 25 25 25 12
Delino Deshields HOU 1 30 30 30 1 Andrew Lambo PIT 1 25 25 25 12
Taylor Lindsey ANA 1 30 30 30 1 Rob Kaminsky STL 1 25 25 25 12
Mason Williams NYA 1 30 30 30 1 Tommy LaStella ATL 1 26 26 26 11
Clayton Blackburn SF 1 26 26 26 11
Cesar Puello NYN 1 26 26 26 11
Gavin Cecchini NYN 1 27 27 27 10
Mason Katz STL 1 27 27 27 10
Rosell Herrera COL 1 27 27 27 10
Marco Gonzales STL 1 27 27 27 10
Luis Heredia PIT 1 28 28 28 9
Eury Perez WAS 1 28 28 28 9
Aaron Altherr PHI 1 28 28 28 9
Phillippe Aumont PHI 1 29 29 29 8
Juan Duran CIN 1 29 29 29 8
Dan Vogelbach CHN 1 29 29 29 8
Jimmy Nelson MIL 1 29 29 29 8
Chris Withrow LA 1 29 29 29 8
Matt DenDekker NYN 1 30 30 30 7
CROSSOVERS
Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score Name Team Votes Avg Best Worst Score
Shin-Soo Choo TEX 34 2.1 1 5 303 Doug Fister WAS 24 1.6 1 5 273
Brian McCann NYA 35 2.6 1 6 294 Jhonny Peralta STL 26 4.3 1 9 225
Carlos Beltran NYA 35 4.6 1 9 224 Mark Trumbo ARI 25 4.2 1 9 220
Jose Abreu CHA 32 4 1 9 224 Curt Granderson NYN 25 4.6 1 9 211
Masahiro Tanaka NYA 26 2.5 1 10 221 Jarrod Saltalamacchia MIA 20 6.1 2 10 138
Dexter Fowler HOU 26 5.8 2 10 136 Justin Morneau COL 19 6.1 1 10 132
Adam Eaton CHA 18 7.6 5 10 61 Josh Johnson SD 17 6.4 1 10 112
David Freese ANA 18 7.8 4 10 58 Bartolo Colon NYN 13 5.3 1 10 100
Alfonso Soriano NYA 17 7.7 3 10 56 Peter Bourjos STL 14 6.1 2 10 96
Tyler Skaggs ANA 16 7.9 3 10 50 Alexander Guerrero LA 12 6.8 3 10 74
Michael Bourn CLE 13 7.2 4 10 50 Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez PHI 10 7.2 3 10 58
Norichika Aoki KC 15 7.7 6 10 50 Brett Anderson COL 8 7.2 5 9 46
Ricky Nolasco MIN 14 8.1 5 10 41 Joaquin Benoit SD 7 6.9 3 10 43
Corey Hart SEA 12 8 6 10 36 Michael Morse SF 7 7.4 3 10 39
Matt Davidson CHA 7 6.7 4 9 30 Addison Reed ARI 6 7.3 5 9 34
Luke Gregerson OAK 6 8 6 10 18 CJ Edwards CHN 6 7.8 4 10 31
Dioner Navarro TOR 6 8.8 6 10 13 Ryan Doumit ATL 5 6.8 4 10 31
Jason Kubel MIN 3 7 5 8 12 Chris_B Young NYN 6 8.8 7 10 25
John Axford CLE 3 7.7 5 10 10 Drew Stubbs COL 3 5 3 9 24
Logan Morrison SEA 3 8 6 9 9 Mike Olt CHN 4 7.5 5 9 22
Cory Rasmus ANA 3 8 5 10 9 Gavin Floyd ATL 1 3 3 3 10
David DeJesus TAM 2 8.5 8 9 5 Nate McLouth WAS 1 10 10 10 3
Kensuke Tanaka TEX 1 6 6 6 5 Roberto Hernandez PHI 1 10 10 10 3
Fernando Salas ANA 1 7 7 7 4
Scott Feldman HOU 1 9 9 9 2
John Buck SEA 1 9 9 9 2
Nick Punto OAK 1 10 10 10 1
Drew Pomeranz OAK 1 10 10 10 1