From other team photos we've managed to identify some of the executives - K.J. Morgan, A.J. Shrubsall, H.A. McDonald, James A. Barclay and Lloyd Turner. In the front row, the player at the left (beside Morgan) is believed to be Lincoln "Dodger" Lewis with Andy Baxter next to Lewis. The player in the second row at the right (beside Barclay) is thought to be S. Guthro and the player in the back row at the left (beside McDonald) is believed to be Fred Lepper.
This is the roster we have compiled for the Hustlers for 1918 :
Baxter Andy 1B/P, Carnegie Joe 3B/1B/2B/MGR, Freeman J. OF/C/3B, Guthro S. 1B/P/OF/2B/3B, Henderson F.(Slim)C/OF, Huffman Charlie OF (also Columbus Club – second half), Isom W. 1B/OF (also Columbus Club – first half), Knee V. OF/C, Lepper Fred SS, Lewis Clifford(Stiffy) P/OF, Lewis Lincoln(Dodger) C/P/OF/1B/SS (also Cubs), Miner OF, Mitchell R.(Scotty) P/OF/SS/2B, Mowery P, Napper P/OF, Smith 2B, Turner C.(Fat) OF/P/3B, Weagant L. OF (also Columbus Club – first half), Wright OF