( ) Valentine Hearts and Rapid City Chiefs each placed three players on the 1967 Basin League all-star team as selected by the Rapid City Journal. The recommendations came from the league's coaches.
Valentine placed catcher Bill Cotton, outfielder Dave Robinson and pitcher Pat Knutzen while the Chiefs landed shortstop Danny Thompson, outfielder Dwight Martinek and pitcher Rick Kester. There were two repeaters from the 1966 squad, Tom Binkowski of Sturgis and Winner pitcher Bob McAulay.
C - Bill Cotton, Valentine (Arizona State), 1B - Tom Binkowski, Sturgis (Michigan State), 2B - Terry Muck, Mobridge (Bethel, MN), 3B - Glen Redmon, Sturgis (Michigan), SS - Danny Thompson, Rapid City (Oklahoma State), OF - Dave Robinson, Valentine (San Diego State), OF - Jim Ziegler, Winner (Colorado State College), OF - Dwight Martinek, Rapid City (Kansas State), P - Rick Kester, Rapid City (UCLA), P - Dave Lemonds, Pierre (North Carolina), P - Pat Knutzen, Valentine (El Camino JC), P - Bob McAulay, Winner,(New Mexico)