JDM | Scoresheet Scoresheet-talk Lists

30px">NATIONAL AMERICAN Best Worst Score CATCHER Best Worst Score 1 10 560 Ivan Rodriguez 1 6 707 1 10 476 Victor Martinez 1 7 702 1 9 454 Jorge Posada 1 8 606 1 9 446 Javy Lopez 1 8 582 1 12 427 Jason Varitek 1 7 477 1 9 402 Joe Mauer 1 10 442 1 10 269 Jason Kendall 1 10 439 1 12 213 A.J. Pierzynski 5 10 166 4 12 188 Brandon Inge 7 10 53 6 11 131 Toby Hall 7 10 53 7 12 53 Bengie Molina 7 10 52 7 12 47 Daric Barton 7 10 52 8 12 34 Matthew LeCroy 6 10 44 7 12 33 Miguel Olivo 8 10 39 5 12 31 John Buck 8 10 37 7 12 29 Jeff Mathis 8 10 10 8 12 27 Rod Barajas 7 10 10 7 11 22 Adam Melhuse 8 8 9 18 Gerald Laird 7 10 7 8 12 17 Gregg Zaun 9 10 5 4 11 17 Guillermo Quiroz 10 10 4 8 12 16 Ryan Garko 8 10 4 9 11 9 Doug Mirabelli 8 10 4 9 11 9 Chris Shelton 9 9 2 8 Ben Davis 9 9 2 5 5 8 Greg Myers 10 10 1 6 Justin Huber 10 10 1 12 12 1 30px">FIRST BASE Best Worst Score FIRST BASE Best Worst Score 1 2 619 Mark Teixeira 1 10 1005 1 3 575 David Ortiz 1 7 962 2 5 516 Carlos Delgado 1 7 915 3 9 441 Travis Hafner 2 15 703 3 12 351 Richie Sexson 1 13 700 4 12 307 Justin Morneau 2 15 674 4 12 262 Paul Konerko 2 15 595 5 12 251 Frank Thomas 3 15 446 4 12 203 Erubiel Durazo 3 15 442 4 12 181 Mike Sweeney 2 15 429 5 12 92 Dmitri Young 5 15 283 5 12 74 Jason Giambi 1 15 271 5 12 59 Kevin Millar 5 15 256 9 12 37 Casey Kotchman 5 15 201 8 12 32 Carlos Pena 3 15 187 7 12 27 Rafael Palmeiro 5 15 161 9 11 9 Darin Erstad 2 15 92 10 12 8 Ben Broussard 6 15 66 9 12 5 Scott Hatteberg 9 15 55 10 10 3 Kendry Morales 7 15 47 11 12 3 Shea Hillenbrand 7 15 36 12 12 1 Ken Harvey 7 15 27 Michael Aubrey 9 15 18 Tino Martinez 11 15 17 Bucky Jacobsen 7 13 12 Dan Johnson 9 12 11 Doug Mientkiewicz 13 15 10 Calvin Pickering 11 15 10 Josh Phelps 12 13 7 Jason Botts 15 15 1 Adrian Gonzalez 15 15 1 30px">SECOND BASE Best Worst Score SECOND BASE Best Worst Score 1 7 563 Alfonso Soriano 1 6 668 1 12 507 Bret Boone 1 10 513 1 10 474 Mark Bellhorn 1 9 450 1 11 469 Orlando Hudson 1 10 417 2 11 358 Brian Roberts 2 10 281 2 12 320 Michael Cuddyer 2 10 260 3 11 254 Chone Figgins 2 10 236 1 12 222 Omar Infante 2 10 215 3 12 219 Ronnie Belliard 2 10 211 4 12 149 Keith Ginter 3 10 191 2 12 86 Adam Kennedy 2 10 83 3 12 69 Tony Womack 3 10 64 6 12 67 Brandon Phillips 4 10 62 47 Jorge Cantu 5 10 58 6 12 39 Mark Ellis 3 10 32 8 12 39 Willie Harris 7 10 15 6 12 26 Luis Rivas 7 10 15 2 12 20 Tony Graffanino 7 10 10 19 Ruben Gotay 7 10 6 10 12 11 Fernando Vina 9 10 3 7 7 6 Frank Menechino 9 9 2 10 12 4 Marcos Scutaro 10 10 2 11 11 4 Robinson Cano 10 10 1 12 12 1 30px">THIRD BASE Best Worst Score THIRD BASE Best Worst Score 1 3 592 Alex Rodriguez 1 4 642 1 7 496 Eric Chavez 1 5 542 2 6 462 Hank Blalock 1 5 525 1 8 436 Adrian Beltre 1 6 513 1 8 399 Aubrey Huff 3 9 347 2 10 379 Melvin Mora 2 8 324 4 12 199 Corey Koskie 5 10 213 6 12 132 Dallas McPherson 4 10 191 6 12 120 Bill Mueller 6 10 143 6 12 120 Casey Blake 6 10 90 5 11 109 Aaron Boone 7 10 39 6 12 73 Eric Hinske 6 10 27 5 12 69 Joe Crede 7 10 26 6 12 63 Kevin Youkilis 9 10 5 7 12 54 Mark Teahen 10 10 1 8 12 48 Billy Butler 10 10 1 6 12 44 Eric Munson 10 10 1 12 12 1 30px">SHORTSTOP Best Worst Score SHORTSTOP Best Worst Score 1 11 498 Miguel Tejada 1 4 627 1 11 446 Derek Jeter 1 8 492 1 7 413 Edgar Renteria 1 9 433 1 11 368 Michael Young 1 10 431 2 10 295 Carlos Guillen 2 10 317 2 12 284 Bobby Crosby 2 10 317 2 12 239 B.J. Upton 1 10 314 2 12 200 Orlando Cabrera 2 10 196 2 12 127 Juan Uribe 4 10 176 4 12 113 Julio Lugo 5 10 70 3 12 92 Angel Berroa 3 10 55 78 Jhonny Peralta 7 10 25 5 12 68 Jose Lopez 3 10 23 6 12 52 Ian Kinsler 4 10 15 5 12 48 Russ Adams 7 7 8 6 12 46 Hanley Ramirez 9 10 6 6 12 42 Jason Bartlett 8 10 5 7 12 34 Pokey Reese 8 10 4 6 10 24 AlexS. Gonzalez(TB) 10 10 2 7 12 20 Aaron Hill 9 9 2 8 12 17 Matt Tuiasosopo 10 10 1 8 12 8 Jose Hernandez 10 10 1 30px">OUTFIELD Best Worst Score OUTFIELD Best Worst Score 1 7 1268 Vladimir Guerrero 1 8 1665 1 9 1243 Manny Ramirez 1 11 1597 2 20 1143 Gary Sheffield 2 11 1490 2 14 1129 Vernon Wells 2 21 1424 2 17 1117 Hideki Matsui 3 27 1383 1 19 1096 Ichiro Suzuki 1 18 1370 2 36 1076 Johnny Damon 1 28 1214 3 22 993 Magglio Ordonez 4 27 1020 6 26 960 Aaron Rowand 3 28 1013 2 19 957 Mark Kotsay 5 28 959 4 28 867 Garret Anderson 3 24 918 4 30 846 Trot Nixon 5 30 901 6 32 732 Carl Crawford 3 27 828 9 26 707 Torii Hunter 5 28 814 10 36 680 Richard Hidalgo 4 28 814 7 31 677 Steve Finley 4 30 688 8 32 609 Shannon Stewart 9 30 614 9 33 588 Lew Ford 10 27 480 7 35 538 Delmon Young 5 30 471 8 36 514 Kevin Mench 5 28 451 7 36 506 Bernie Williams 8 30 406 15 34 495 Jeremy Reed 8 30 395 4 36 481 David Dejesus 8 30 383 9 34 477 Randy Winn 5 30 349 10 33 472 Jacque Jones 12 30 317 11 35 466 Rocco Baldelli 11 29 312 3 34 452 Nick Swisher 11 30 299 13 36 420 Jermaine Dye 8 30 298 13 34 410 Scott Podsednik 2 30 294 14 36 325 Raul Ibanez 1 30 290 15 33 292 Grady Sizemore 11 30 289 16 36 247 Eric Byrnes 14 30 287 12 36 174 Alexis Rios 7 30 250 14 35 129 Coco Crisp 8 30 225 18 36 115 Laynce Nix 12 30 199 26 34 97 Carl Everett 8 30 180 25 36 66 Jose Cruz 14 30 160 23 36 62 Jason Kubel 16 30 101 18 34 54 Juan Gonzalez 9 29 94 23 34 51 Frank Catalanotto 13 29 86 24 35 49 Rondell White 16 29 85 23 36 39 Craig Monroe 15 29 73 37 Tim Salmon 9 30 68 26 36 35 Jody Gerut 17 29 62 27 36 30 Juan Rivera 21 27 57 26 32 29 Danny Bautista 19 30 49 19 33 27 Reed Johnson 20 27 46 27 Jay Gibbons 15 29 45 29 36 25 Jerry Hairston 24 28 32 30 36 25 Franklin Gutierrez 17 29 28 25 36 24 Joe Borchard 11 27 24 29 35 23 Jay Payton 23 28 19 29 36 14 Alex Sanchez 25 30 15 27 36 12 Shin-Soo Choo 24 30 15 27 27 10 Bobby Higginson 25 30 12 9 Ruben Sierra 19 19 12 30 36 8 Terrence Long 23 28 11 29 29 8 Luis Matos 21 21 10 34 36 6 Gary Matthews 25 27 10 36 36 2 Jeff DaVanon 27 29 9 35 35 2 Larry Bigbie 26 29 7 35 35 2 Ryan Sweeney 26 30 6 35 35 2 Brandon Moss 26 26 5 Michael Restovich 27 27 4 Jonny Gomes 29 29 2 Javier Herrera(Oak) 29 29 2 Brian Anderson(ChA) 29 29 2 Ross Gload 30 30 1 Val Majewski 30 30 1 30px">STARTER Best Worst Score STARTER Best Worst Score 1 19 1477 Johan Santana 1 6 2232 1 16 1455 Curt Schilling 2 7 2107 2 19 1447 Randy Johnson 1 50 2100 1 50 1418 Rich Harden 2 44 1850 1 28 1408 Roy Halladay 3 46 1766 1 32 1375 Mike Mussina 2 39 1737 4 44 1327 Barry Zito 1 32 1712 2 42 1292 Mark Buehrle 1 30 1709 3 24 1251 C.C. Sabathia 5 28 1658 4 45 1222 Brad Radke 4 36 1623 1 47 1214 Freddy Garcia 4 30 1579 5 45 1198 Carl Pavano 4 30 1565 8 33 1119 Bartolo Colon 5 41 1527 2 35 1072 Kelvim Escobar 4 30 1518 11 48 1040 Matt Clement 5 32 1509 7 54 1021 Jeremy Bonderman 5 42 1291 1 41 1014 Zack Greinke 2 36 1287 9 55 1000 Joel Pineiro 8 44 1275 9 49 983 Kevin Millwood 7 43 1150 5 46 957 Scott Kazmir 7 48 1098 9 58 947 Jaret Wright 11 48 1096 14 48 923 Ted Lilly 11 47 1088 13 41 893 Jake Westbrook 9 48 1020 2 60 864 Bronson Arroyo 6 46 958 15 54 829 David Wells 6 49 943 10 55 791 Kevin Brown(NYA) 8 50 881 8 54 777 Rodrigo Lopez 13 47 862 10 60 766 Wade Miller 12 49 843 14 56 754 John Lackey 8 47 837 12 58 747 Jose Contreras 18 46 705 12 59 727 Cliff Lee 17 48 701 8 58 677 Danny Haren 14 47 663 8 54 669 Sidney Ponson 8 50 633 13 55 659 Jarrod Washburn 19 48 583 19 47 647 David Bush 17 50 557 15 53 640 Felix Hernandez 5 47 556 17 58 627 Joe Blanton 11 49 538 12 60 616 Jon Garland 6 50 495 15 57 599 Tim Wakefield 13 49 482 12 52 556 Nate Robertson 13 49 474 16 55 553 Miguel Batista 11 50 445 18 53 510 Mike Maroth 7 50 424 27 54 493 Orlando Hernandez 15 50 423 25 58 463 Jamie Moyer 10 48 410 31 54 382 Kenny Rogers 11 50 407 13 60 360 Carlos Silva 15 48 403 21 60 329 Gil Meche 22 50 366 16 58 316 Ryan Drese 5 50 336 9 60 308 Bobby Madritsch 13 49 305 25 57 296 Ryan Franklin 18 50 261 23 60 286 Jason Johnson 20 48 254 27 60 278 Dan Meyer 27 50 233 32 58 255 Kyle Lohse 25 50 226 23 59 237 Erik Bedard 28 50 223 28 59 235 Wilfredo Ledezma 27 50 191 24 59 203 Paul Byrd 21 50 184 35 54 192 Adam Miller 19 50 167 26 60 191 Daniel Cabrera 28 49 163 28 55 188 Matt Riley 25 50 118 39 59 168 Mark Hendrickson 17 47 117 23 58 166 Jose Lima 31 50 113 27 59 164 Ervin(Johan) Santana 30 49 98 29 60 161 Dewon Brazelton 30 49 91 33 58 161 Juan Dominguez 31 49 87 30 57 148 Joaquin Benoit 24 48 85 39 60 134 Kurt Ainsworth 11 49 84 15 60 114 John Maine 33 50 73 27 57 103 J.D. Durbin 30 49 69 36 59 93 Scott Elarton 38 49 65 28 60 93 Byung-Hyun Kim 31 48 60 39 54 92 Justin Duchscherer 30 46 59 39 59 92 Brian Anderson(KC) 33 49 56 37 54 88 Brandon McCarthy 32 50 51 22 59 84 John Danks 30 49 48 39 60 83 Jimmy Gobble 38 49 45 34 59 81 Rafael Soriano 23 35 44 51 Kris Honel 30 38 34 32 60 47 Bruce Chen 31 39 32 31 60 39 Scott Baker 30 50 29 48 59 34 Denny Bautista 42 49 29 48 57 34 Gustavo Chacin 43 48 27 31 Ron Villone 25 25 26 46 60 24 Dustin McGowan 30 49 25 50 57 24 Adam Loewen 31 50 24 42 42 19 Dustin Hermanson 29 49 24 44 44 17 Thomas Diamond 30 50 22 51 57 14 Mike Wood 35 46 21 53 60 14 Chris Young 41 47 19 54 59 13 Runelvys Hernandez 35 48 19 11 Kyle Sleeth 35 49 18 50 50 11 Justin Verlander 41 44 17 54 60 11 Jorge Sosa 34 34 17 9 Ricardo Rodriguez 39 48 15 52 52 9 Eric DuBose 41 47 14 54 54 7 Clint Nageotte 45 48 13 54 54 7 Scott Schoeneweis 40 40 11 54 54 7 Josh Rupe 42 42 9 55 55 6 ChanHo Park 42 42 9 6 Doug Waechter 42 42 9 55 55 6 Tanyon Sturtze 44 44 7 55 55 6 John Halama 46 50 6 5 Gary Knotts 45 45 6 56 56 5 Kevin Appier 46 46 5 56 56 5 Francisco Liriano 46 46 5 57 57 4 Chris George 46 46 5 57 57 4 Joel Zumaya 47 47 4 60 60 1 Jason Stanford 47 47 4 60 60 1 Travis Blackley 47 47 4 Joe Mays 48 50 4 Chad Gaudin 50 50 1 Jeremy Sowers 50 50 1 Fausto Carmona 50 50 1 Colby Lewis 50 50 1 Huston Street 50 50 1 30px">RELIEVER Best Worst Score RELIEVER Best Worst Score 1 2 381 Mariano Rivera 1 6 414 1 7 335 Keith Foulke 1 5 372 2 8 252 Francisco Rodriguez 1 6 360 3 12 200 Joe Nathan 1 10 239 2 11 198 Octavio Dotel 1 9 205 3 11 175 Francisco Cordero 3 10 193 2 12 164 B.J. Ryan 1 10 154 3 12 164 Tom Gordon 2 10 134 5 11 133 Scot Shields 2 10 80 2 12 86 Damaso Marte 4 10 55 5 12 71 Juan Rincon 2 10 42 4 12 68 Brendan Donnelly 4 10 42 4 12 57 Troy Percival 4 9 38 5 12 42 Juan Cruz 4 10 37 4 12 41 Jesse Crain 4 10 28 4 11 21 Shingo Takatsu 4 10 27 8 12 11 Eddie Guardado 6 10 20 8 12 11 Danys Baez 6 10 20 10 12 9 Jeremy Affeldt 8 10 14 9 9 8 Ugueth Urbina 7 10 13 8 10 8 Rafael Betancourt 6 10 9 8 12 8 Jorge Julio 7 9 8 6 6 7 Paul Quantrill 3 3 8 6 6 7 Mike Timlin 5 10 8 10 11 7 Kevin Gregg 6 9 7 9 12 7 Chad Bradford 7 10 7 7 7 6 Felix Rodriguez 7 10 7 8 8 5 Kiko Calero 5 5 6 4 Ron Mahay 6 10 6 11 12 3 Billy Koch 5 5 6 11 12 3 Mike Stanton 6 6 5 2 David Riske 8 10 5 12 12 1 J.C. Romero 7 10 5 12 12 1 Jesus Colome 6 6 5 Justin Speier 8 8 3 Bob Wickman 8 8 3 Shigetoshi Hasegawa 9 9 2 Steve Kline 9 9 2 Lance Carter 9 9 2 30px">ROOKIE Best Worst Score ROOKIE Best Worst Score 1 19 479 Dallas McPherson 1 20 676 1 17 476 Delmon Young 1 14 649 1 18 404 Felix Hernandez 1 11 607 1 23 366 Joe Blanton 1 18 528 3 19 342 Jeremy Reed 1 19 511 3 24 332 Daric Barton 1 19 483 1 23 293 Nick Swisher 2 19 465 2 23 240 Adam Miller 3 16 355 2 24 239 Jason Kubel 1 18 347 1 24 236 Ian Kinsler 4 20 296 3 22 233 Dan Meyer 4 18 295 4 23 216 Hanley Ramirez 6 19 262 1 24 208 Kendry Morales 3 19 247 3 24 206 Michael Aubrey 5 20 209 2 24 194 Ervin(Johan) Santana 4 20 202 2 24 187 J.D. Durbin 2 18 197 2 24 186 Jeff Mathis 2 20 184 7 24 166 John Maine 1 17 143 2 23 148 Huston Street 4 20 124 2 21 124 Mark Teahen 3 20 116 3 23 124 Adam Loewen 3 20 116 5 22 122 Shin-Soo Choo 2 19 95 2 24 121 Kyle Sleeth 6 18 86 2 18 113 Dustin McGowan 8 19 85 4 23 99 Franklin Gutierrez 5 20 80 4 23 91 Scott Baker 6 17 72 6 22 89 Adrian Gonzalez 2 20 69 8 20 76 Joey Gathright 3 18 69 6 24 75 Brandon McCarthy 6 19 68 8 24 66 John Danks 10 19 68 4 23 63 Eric Duncan 7 16 63 2 24 63 Thomas Diamond 6 20 62 10 24 62 Justin Verlander 10 19 57 2 23 56 Jason Bartlett 5 19 52 4 21 55 Jeremy Guthrie 3 20 51 5 20 52 Kris Honel 2 16 51 3 23 50 Dan Johnson 5 20 51 6 23 49 Robinson Cano 5 19 50 8 23 41 Guillermo Quiroz 13 20 50 11 24 41 Justin Huber 8 20 47 14 23 39 Kenny Baugh 5 17 45 9 18 39 Brian Anderson(ChA) 10 20 45 2 19 39 Chris Snelling 6 19 43 8 24 37 Ryan Sweeney 7 18 41 11 22 35 Jason Arnold 12 17 38 8 23 33 Jeremy Sowers 8 18 38 5 23 33 Gustavo Chacin 9 20 37 15 15 30 Joel Zumaya 6 14 35 7 24 29 Jairo Garcia 11 16 31 1 22 27 Erick Aybar 13 18 30 7 17 26 Jamal Strong 5 8 29 6 22 26 Nicholas Markakis 4 18 29 8 17 25 Boof Bonser 8 18 28 6 21 23 Josh Hamilton 4 10 28 15 24 22 Curtis Granderson 7 19 25 17 24 22 Aaron Hill 10 18 25 6 24 20 Brandon League 6 20 24 14 16 20 Jonny Gomes 5 20 23 9 9 16 Kelly Shoppach 12 16 21 15 Alberto Callaspo 2 20 20 11 11 14 Brandon Wood 11 20 17 12 12 13 J.D. Martin 7 18 17 12 12 13 Dustin Moseley 5 5 16 13 13 12 Arnie Munoz 9 18 15 14 14 11 Jon Lester 9 9 12 16 23 11 Dustin Pedroia 10 20 12 14 14 11 Glen Perkins 15 19 8 10 Kameron Loe 14 20 8 18 23 9 Francisco Rosario 14 14 7 17 17 8 Billy Butler 16 20 7 21 22 7 Jon Papelbon 17 20 6 20 20 5 Ryan Garko 19 20 5 21 24 5 Howie Kendrick 17 20 5 20 20 5 Brandon Moss 16 16 5 20 20 5 Chris Lubanski 19 20 4 20 20 5 Francisco Cruceta 19 20 3 20 20 5 Val Majewski 19 19 2 21 21 4 Bradley Snyder 19 19 2 3 David Purcey 19 19 2 3 J.P. Howell 19 19 2 23 23 2 Fernando Cabrera 20 20 1 Terry Tiffee 20 20 1 30px">CROSSOVER Best Worst Score CROSSOVER Best Worst Score 1 5 633 Adrian Beltre 1 6 599 1 6 550 Randy Johnson 1 4 594 1 12 537 Matt Clement 2 9 347 7 497 Richie Sexson 2 10 308 1 12 413 Edgar Renteria 2 10 304 2 12 399 Scott Kazmir 3 9 290 4 11 292 Carl Pavano 2 9 281 2 12 272 Jason Kendall 3 10 231 6 12 192 Kevin Millwood 4 10 120 6 12 145 Richard Hidalgo 3 10 88 4 12 118 Wade Miller 2 10 75 7 12 92 Orlando Cabrera 5 10 63 9 12 29 Jaret Wright 5 10 52 9 12 29 Danny Haren 2 10 44 7 12 18 Steve Finley 6 10 42 9 12 17 Daric Barton 2 10 29 10 12 13 A.J. Pierzynski 8 10 13 10 12 11 Scott Podsednik 8 10 8 9 12 9 Dan Meyer 6 10 8 7 12 9 Steve Kline 5 5 6 11 12 6 Keith Ginter 8 10 5 8 12 6 Ugueth Urbina 7 7 4 12 12 2 Juan Cruz 9 9 4 12 12 1 Shea Hillenbrand 10 10 2 Paul Byrd 10 10 1 Orlando Hernandez 10 10 1 Gary Matthews 10 10 1 bgcolor="#804040"> bgcolor="#804040"> bgcolor="#804040">


	Scoresheet--talk / Best, by position 2005

	These lists are the result of polls on the Scoresheet-talk list. Rankings are based on a unscientific poll of subscribers to the Scoresheet-talk list. Members are asked to rank players for a regular continuing league beginning in 2005. Votes are counted on a 10,9,8 ... (or, in the NL, 12,11,10 ...) basis. Thanks here to the SS-talk moderators, especially Brian Jones, who have continued this SS-talk tradition and to William Burke for setting up an online mechanism to handle the voting.

bgcolor="#804040">